Site last updated 1st February 2012
Peak District Air Accident Research

Peak District Air Accident Research

Peak District Air Accident Research

 

Boeing B-17G 44-8639 of the 351st Bombardment Group, USAAF, crashed on Craig Cwm Llwyd on the 8th June 1945.

 

Boeing B-17 at RAF Mildenhall

 

Crew / Passengers Rank - If Applicable Position e.g. Pilot Status
Howard R. Hibbard 1st Lieutenant Pilot Killed  
Joseph C. Robinson Captain Co-pilot Killed
Joseph A. Glover Captain Navigator Killed
John Q. Montgomery Master Sergeant Engineer / Crew Chief Killed
Max Marksheid Technical Sergeant Radio Operator Killed
Santo A. Caruso Staff Sergeant Gunner Killed 
Kenneth W. Craumer Technical Sergeant Gunner Killed
David I. Rapoport Sergeant Gunner Killed
Lester A.F. Rhein Technical Sergeant Gunner Killed
Robert E. Smith Staff Sergeant Gunner Killed
Richard E. Higley 1st Lieutenant Passenger Killed  
Teed O. Smith Staff Sergeant Passenger Killed
Morris Lemewski Technical Sergeant Passenger Killed
Paul Lucyk DFC Technical Sergeant Passenger Killed
Edwin R. Birtwell Sergeant Passenger Killed
Sheldon R. Coons Sergeant Passenger Killed
Camille F. Devaney Sergeant Passenger Killed
Boyd P. Dobbs Sergeant Passenger Killed
John D. Leasure Sergeant Passenger Killed
Calvert G. Pool Corporal Passenger Killed

 

Following the end of conflict in Europe US Forces began to return home, some as their period of service came to an end and others in preparation for the expected attack on Japan. Most returned by sea but some USAAF personnel returned by air. This aircraft was one of many that were being flown back to the USA with those additional passengers. It was being flown from Polebrook in Northamptonshire to RAF Valley on Anglesey before the final leg back to the USA, on board was a crew of ten with another ten passengers. As with a number of other flights engaged in this operation it never left the British Isles.

While approaching Valley in low visibility the crew requested a course to steer and this was transmitted to them by Valley, however the aircraft flew on the reciprocal course which took it inland towards Dolgellau. After a short while the crew realised the error and began a turn to starboard to take them back out to sea. Before this turn was completed it struck high ground close to the summit of Craig Cwm Llwyd on the southern side of the Mawddach Estuary, it travelled approximately 300 feet along the crags before its last impact where the wreck broke up and was destroyed by fire.

 

Memorial plaque below the crash site on Craig Cwm Llwyd, Copyright - Peak District Air Accident Research

In 1995 this plaque commemorating the 20 US servicemen was attached to the wall beside the footpath and track below the crash site by Matthew Rimmer of Dolgellau.

 

View towards Barmouth from the crash site memorial

The plaque with Barmouth Bridge and the town of Barmouth in the background.

 

The crash site on Craig Cwm Llwyd

The crash site itself is marked by this scar on the hillside above the memorial.

 

View from the crash site of B-17G 44-8639 on Craig Cwm Llwyd towards Barmouth

Looking back down from the site.

 

Eleven of those killed were subsequently buried at Cambridge American Cemetery, below are photographs of nine of their graves.

Pilot, 1st Lt Hibbard

Grave at Cambridge American Cemetery of Pilot, 1st Lieutenant Howard R. Hibbard

Navigator, Captain Glover

Grave of Captain Joseph A. Glover at Cambridge American Cemetery

Engineer / Crew Chief, Master Sergeant Montgomery

Grave of Engineer, Master Sergeant John O. Montgomery at Cambridge American Cemetery

Gunner Staff Sergeant Caruso

Grave of Staff Sergeant Santo A. Caruso at Cambridge American Cemetery

Gunner, Staff Sergeant Smith

Grave of Staff Sergeant Robert E Smith at Cambridge American Cemetery

 

Passengers:

Sergeant Birtwell

Grave of Sergeant Edwin R Birtwell at Cambridge American Cemetery

Sergeant Coons

Grave of Sheldon R. Coons at Cambridge American Cemetery

Sergeant Dobbs

Grave of Sergeant Boyd P. Dobbs at Cambridge American Cemetery

1st Lt Higley

Grave of 1st Lieutenant Richard E. Higley at Cambridge American Cemetery

Technical Sergeant Lucyk

Grave of Technical Sergeant Paul Lucyk at Cambridge American Cemetery

Staff Sergeant Smith

Grave of Staff Sergeant Teed O. Smith at Cambridge American Cemetery

BACK